Side-by-side comparison
Sonlight vs The Good and the Beautiful
A side-by-side from Sonlight Curriculum and The Good and the Beautiful.
Sonlight and The Good and the Beautiful are two of the most-searched Christian homeschool curricula on the internet, but they represent almost opposite approaches to a Christian homeschool day. Families comparing them are usually choosing between a deeply book-based read-aloud program and an open-and-go, beautifully designed integrated curriculum. The cost difference is also significant.
Sonlight, in print since 1990, is parent-led, read-aloud-heavy, and book-rich. The History / Bible / Literature cores walk the family through historical fiction, biographies, and primary sources via daily Instructor's Guides. All-Subjects Packages run ~$700 per student. The Christian worldview is global and missions-focused, and the program covers PreK through 12. The daily commitment is real — read-alouds typically take 45–90 minutes plus the rest of the subjects. The strength is depth and discussion; the cost is time.
The Good and the Beautiful (TGTB), founded by Jenny Phillips in 2015, has grown faster than almost any other curriculum in the homeschool market. The Language Arts and Math PDFs for K–8 are genuinely free downloads; printed Course Sets run $49–$124 per level. Lessons are integrated (reading, grammar, spelling, phonics, vocabulary, art, and geography combined into single Language Arts lessons of 20–30 minutes), open-and-go, and visually beautiful. TGTB is Charlotte Mason-inspired with LDS roots; the publisher markets it as broadly non-denominational Christian with occasional KJV scripture references.
The worldview difference matters: Sonlight's Christianity is evangelical-Protestant and globally minded; TGTB's Christianity reflects LDS-influenced sensibilities even though it's marketed as cross-denominational. Some non-LDS Christian families are comfortable with TGTB; some prefer to know what's in their curriculum.
At a glance
The specifics
| Sonlight | The Good and the Beautiful | |
|---|---|---|
| Publisher | Sonlight Curriculum | The Good and the Beautiful |
| Established | 1990 | 2015 |
| Price | $250–$700/year | $0–$124/grade |
| Grades | PreK, K–2, 3–5, 6–8, 9–12 | PreK, K–2, 3–5, 6–8, 9–12 |
| Subject | Language Arts, Science, History, Bible, Full Program | Math, Language Arts, Full Program |
| Method | Literature Based | Charlotte Mason |
| Format | Print, Digital | |
| Worldview | Christian | Christian |
The verdict
How to choose
Choose Sonlight if you want depth, you love read-alouds, you have multiple children and value the family-style approach, your family is comfortable with evangelical-Protestant Christianity, or you need a curriculum through high school. It's the right call for families who want a homeschool that revolves around great books.
Choose The Good and the Beautiful if budget matters (the free PDFs are genuinely a feature), you want open-and-go with minimal planning, your child responds to visually beautiful materials, or you prefer Charlotte Mason-inspired integrated lessons over long read-alouds. Preview the religious content first if your theology is sensitive to LDS-influenced sources — most non-LDS families are fine, but it's worth checking.
Read the full reviews
Keep exploring
More comparisons
Picked one?
Track your curriculum with Homeschool Fox
Log activities by voice or text and stay compliant with your state's requirements automatically.
No credit card required.